福彩500走势图

2020年02月19日 星期三
| | 地质云 : |
中国矿业报订阅

采矿权租赁合同效力认定的变迁

2019-9-11 8:37:00 来源:中国矿业报 作者:范小强

《关于审理矿业权纠纷案件适用法律若干问题的解释》出台的意义

2017NIAN6YUE24RI,ZUIGAORENMINFAYUANFABU《GUANYUSHENLIKUANGYEQUANJIUFENANJIANSHIYONGFALVRUOGANWENTIDEJIESHI》((FASHI〔2017〕12HAO,YIXIAJIANCHENG12HAOWEN)),ZI2017NIAN7YUE27RIQISHIXING。ZHEISHIWOGUOSIFASHIJIANZAIKUANGYEWUQUANBAOHUZHONGQUDEDEYOUYIXIANGZHONGYAOCHENGJIU。KEYISHUO,12HAOWENDEBANXINGSHISIFAJIGUANDUIYUKUANGYEQUANJIUFENCAIPANGUIZEGONGJIBUZUDEJIZHONGHUIYING,KEWEISHISIFACAIPANGUIZECENGMIANDEGONGJICEGAIGE。

TONGSHI《GUANYUSHENLIKUANGYEQUANJIUFENANJIANSHIYONGFALVRUOGANWENTIDEJIESHI》DEBANBUSHISHIDUIJISHIHUAJIEKUANGYEQUANJIUFEN,BAOHUGUOJIALIYIHEKUANGYEQUANRENHEFAQUANYI,CUJINKUANGYELVSEFAZHANYEJUYOUSHIFENZHONGYAODEYIYI。

SHIWUZHONG,RUHEZHENGQUELIJIEYUSHIYONGGAIBUSIFAJIESHISHIFALVGONGZUOZHEDEZHONGDARENWUZHIYI。KUANGYEWUQUANZUOWEIYONGYIWUQUANDEZHONGYAOZUCHENGBUFEN,QIBINGFEIDANCHUNYOU《WUQUANFA》DIAOZHENG,ERSHIYINGDANGCHONGFENZHUYIDAOQITAGUANLIANFALVZHIDUZAISHENLIKUANGYEQUANJIUFENANJIANZHONGDERONGHEXINGSHIYONGWENTI,YINCIDUIGAISIFAJIESHIJINXINGZONGHEXINGJIEXIYUYANJIU,JUYOUZHONGYAODESIFASHIJIANJIAZHI。

《GUANYUSHENLIKUANGYEQUANJIUFENANJIANSHIYONGFALVRUOGANWENTIDEJIESHI》DESHISHIYIWEIZHE,JIANGKUANGYEQUANZULINYUKUANGYEQUANZHUANRANGJINXINGQUFENDESIFAGUANDIANQUDELEYOUSHI,ERJIEHEDIANXINGANLIBINGHUIGUSHENPANJIGUANGUANYUCAIKUANGQUANZULINHETONGXIAOLIRENDINGDEBIANQIANJUYOUXIANSHIYIYI。

一、案情回放

福彩500走势图 2001NIAN10YUE6RI,CHENMOUYULIAONINGSHENGKUANDIANMANZUZIZHIXIANHUSHANZHENLAOBIANQIANGCUNMINWEIYUANHUIQIANDING《LAOBIANQIANGJINKUANGZULINXIEYISHU》,YUEDING:CUNWEIHUITONGGUOZHAOBIAOJIANGLAOBIANQIANGJINKUANGZULINJICHENMOUKAICAIJINGYING,KAICAIJINGYINGQIXIANWEI5NIAN,JIZI2001NIAN10YUEZHI2006NIAN10YUE,CHENMOUYICIXINGXIANGCUNWEIHUIJIAONA5NIANDEJINGJIBUCHANGJIN,BINGANZHONGBIAOSHUEDE20%YICIXINGXIANGSUOZAIZHENZHENGFUJIAONABUCHANGJIN;JINKUANGSUOYOUSHOUXUYOUCHENGBAOZHEZIXINGBANLI,FEIYONGZIFU。RUYINYOUGUANSHOUXUBANLIBUTUOWUFAKAICAI,ZUJINBUYUFANHAI,SUOZAOCHENGDESUNSHIYIYOUCHENMOUZIFU,SHEBEI、DIANLI、MAOTAISHANGKUANGSHIJIKUANGJINGNEIYUANCHENGBAOZHEKAICAIDEKUANGSHIGUIYUANCHENGBAOZHESUOYOU;ZAIZULINQINEIKUANGSHANCHANSHENGDEYIQIEJINGJI、FALVZERENJUNYOUCHENMOUCHENGDAN,CUNWEIHUIBUCHENGDANRENHEZEREN。YOUYULAOBIANQIANGJINKUANGYUANCHENGBAORENCHENGMOUWEIJISHIJIANGQISHEBEICONGDIYIJINKUANGCHECHU,ZHISHICHENMOUBUNENGYIJUXIEYIYUEDINGZHENGCHANGJINGYINGGAIKUANG。YUANLIAONINGSHENGGUOTUZIYUANTINGZHIBANFALEDIERJINKUANG2002NIANHE2005NIANDECAIKUANGXUKEZHENG,2001NIAN、2003NIANHE2004NIANDECAIKUANGXUKEZHENGWEIYUBANLIHEBANFA。

XIEYIQIANDINGHOU,CHENMOUYIYUEYICIXINGJIAOQINGLEBUCHANGJIN(JIZUJIN)54WANYUAN。2001NIAN10YUE14RI,CUNWEIHUITIANBAO《CAIKUANGQUANCHUZUSHENQINGDENGJIBIAO》,CIBIAOZAIMINGZULINQIXIANWEI5NIAN,KUANDIANMANZUZIZHIXIANDIKUANGBANGONGSHIJIYUANDANDONGSHIGUIHUAHEGUOTUZIYUANJUQIANSHUTONGYI,DANWEIJINGYUANLIAONINGSHENGGUOTUZIYUANTINGSHENPI。CHENMOUJINGYINGLAOBIANQIANGJINKUANGQIJIAN,DUIKUANGSHANDEJINGXIANGGONGCHENGJINXINGLEZENGJIAN。JINGPINGGU,CHENMOUZENGJIANDEKUANGSHANJINGXIANGGONGCHENGJIAZHI706874.9YUAN。

2006NIAN10YUE9RI,CUNWEIHUIYUCHENGMOUQIANDING《KUANDIANXIANHUSHANZHENLAOBIANQIANGCUNDIERJINKUANGCAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGXIEYISHU》。CIHOU,CHENGMOUYOUJIANGGAIKUANGDECAIKUANGXUKEZHENGBANLIDAOZIJIMINGXIA,CHENGWEIGAIKUANGDECAIKUANGQUANREN,YOUXIAOQIZHI2012NIAN3YUE7RI。CUNWEIHUIXIANYIBUSHIDIYIJINKUANG、DIERJINKUANGDECAIKUANGQUANREN。

二、原告方诉讼请求与法院判决

【原告方诉讼请求】

CHENMOU2006NIAN8YUE8RIXIANGLIAONINGSHENGDANDONGSHIZHONGJIRENMINFAYUANQISU,QINGQIUFAYUANPANLING:1.CUNWEIHUILVXINGHETONGYUEDINGDEJIANGDIYIJINKUANGJIAOJIQIJINGYINGDEYIWU;2.RUBUNENGJIAOFU,YOUDIERJINKUANGDAIWEILVXING;3.CUNWEIHUISHUNYANLVXINGDIERJINKUANGDEHETONGQIXIAN3NIAN;4.CUNWEIHUIPEICHANGQIJINGJISUNSHI160WANYUAN。

【FAYUANPANJUE】

福彩500走势图DANDONGZHONGYUANYISHENBOHUICHENMOUDESUSONGQINGQIU。CHENMOUSHANGSUHOU,LIAONINGGAOYUANERSHENWEICHIYUANPAN。

CHENMOUBUFUERSHENSHENGXIAOPANJUE,SHENQINGZAISHEN。LIAONINGGAOYUANYU2009NIAN8YUE14RIZUOCHU(2008)LIAOMINZAIZIDI26HAOMINSHIPANJUE,WEICHI(2007)LIAOMINERZHONGZIDI91HAOMINSHIPANJUE。

CHENMOUBUFULIAONINGGAOYUANZAISHENPANJUE,JIXUSHENSU,ZUIGAOFAYUANYI(2011)MINTIZIDI81HAOWEICHILIAONINGSHENGGAOJIRENMINFAYUAN(2008)LIAOMINZAIZIDI26HAOMINSHIPANJUE。

三、 关于涉案《老边墙金矿租赁协议书》的效力问题

ZUIGAORENMINFAYUANSHENGXIAOPANJUERENWEI,CAIKUANGYESHUYUTEXUXINGYE,GENJUYOUGUANFALV、XINGZHENGFAGUIDEGUIDING,QUDESHEANJINKUANGDECAIKUANGQUANHEZULINQUANDOUYAOJINGGUOYUANLIAONINGSHENGGUOTUZIYUANTINGDESHENPI,QIZHONGRENHEYIXIANGQUANLIWEIJINGPIZHUN,QICAIKUANGXINGWEIBUSHOUFALVBAOHU。

GENJU《TANKUANGQUANCAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGGUANLIBANFA》DISHITIAODISANKUANJI《KUANGYEQUANCHURANGZHUANRANGGUANLIZANXINGGUIDING》(GUOTUZIFA[2000]309HAO,YIXIAJIANCHENG309HAOWEN)DISANSHILIUTIAODIERKUANGUIDING,ZUIGAORENMINFAYUANRENDING,SHEANZULINXIEYISUIRANYIHEFACHENGLI,DANSHANGWEISHENGXIAO,YINCIGAIXIEYITIAOKUANDUISHUANGFANGDANGSHIRENMEIYOUYUESHULI,YEBUCHANSHENGWEIYUEZEREN。

四、关于该案法律适用的过程

BENANDEGUANJIANWENTISHI《LAOBIANQIANGJINKUANGZULINXIEYISHU》DEXIAOLI,HETONGXIAOLIWENTIJIEJUEHOU,QITAWENTIJIUYINGRENERJIE。

1.识别法律关系

福彩500走势图TONGGUOFENXISHEAN《LAOBIANQIANGJINKUANGZULINGAOSHI》HE《LAOBIANQIANGJINKUANGZULINXIEYISHU》,ZUIGAOYUANRENDING:LIANGZHEJUNSHUYUHETONGDEZUCHENGBUFEN,《LAOBIANQIANGJINKUANGZULINXIEYISHU》SHIDUI《LAOBIANQIANGJINKUANGZULINGAOSHI》DEQUERENHEBUCHONG;BENANSHICHUZURENCUNWEIHUIYUCHENGZURENYIN《LAOBIANQIANGJINKUANGZULINXIEYISHU》DELVXINGFASHENGDEJIUFEN。

ZAICAIKUANGQUANFALVGUANXIZHONG,CUNWEIHUISHICAIKUANGQUANREN,SHUANGFANGYUEDINGZULINDESHICAIKUANGQUANERFEIBAOKUOCAIKUANGSHEBEIZAINEIDEZHENGGEKUANGSHAN。

2.选择适用法律规范

SHEAN《LAOBIANQIANGJINKUANGZULINXIEYISHU》QIANDINGYU2001NIAN10YUE,DANGSHISHENGXIAODEFALVFAGUIZHUYAOYOU:《KUANGCHANZIYUANFA》(1996NIANXIUZHENG)、《KUANGCHANZIYUANFASHISHIXIZE》(1994NIAN)、《TANKUANGQUANCAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGGUANLIBANFA》(1998NIANDE309HAOWEN)、《LIAONINGSHENGKUANGCHANZIYUANGUANLITIAOLI》(1997NIAN)。

ZAISHANGSHUFALVGUIFANXINGWENJIANZHONG,FALVHEXINGZHENGFAGUIBINGMEIYOUGUIDINGCAIKUANGQUANZULIN,ERDIFANGXINGFAGUI《LIAONINGSHENGKUANGCHANZIYUANGUANLITIAOLI》JI《KUANGYEQUANCHURANGZHUANRANGGUANLIZANXINGGUIDING》DUICAIKUANGQUANDIYAYOUSUOGUIDING。YUSHICHUXIANLEYIGEWENTI,JIFAYUANRUHEXUANZESHIYONGFALV?

DUICI,《QUANGUOMINSHIANJIANSHENPANZHILIANGGONGZUOZUOTANHUIJIYAO》(FA[1999]231HAO)MINGQUELEFALVSHIYONGYUANZE,JI“ZAICHULIGELEIMINSHIANJIANSHI,DUIYUGUOJIAFALV、XINGZHENGFAGUIYOUGUIDING,ERDIFANGXINGFAGUIHEGEZHONGGUIZHANGZHONGGUIDINGDENEIRONG,SHUYUJIEHEDANGDISHIJIQINGKUANGERDUIYOUGUANLIFAJINGSHENHEYUANZEJUTIHUA、TIAOWENHUA,JIAYIMINGQUEFANWEIHEBIAOZHUNDE,YINGDANGSHIYONGHUOZHECANZHAO;DUIYUGUOJIAFALV、XINGZHENGFAGUISHANGWUMINGQUEGUIDING,DIFANGXINGFAGUIHUOGUIZHANGDEGUIDINGBUWEIFANGUOJIAFALVDEJIBENYUANZEDE,KEYISHIYONGHUOZHECANZHAO;YUFALV、XINGZHENGFAGUIGUIDINGDEJIBENYUANZEHEJINGSHENXIANGDICHUDE,BUNENGSHIYONGHUOZHECANZHAO。”

福彩500走势图GENJU《LIAONINGSHENGKUANGCHANZIYUANGUANLITIAOLI》(1997NIAN)DISISHIBATIAO“FEIFAMAIMAI、CHUZUHUOZHEYIQITAFANGSHIZHUANRANGTANKUANGQUAN、CAIKUANGQUANDE,YOUXIANYISHANGDIKUANGZHUGUANBUMENMEISHOUWEIFASUODE,DUIDANGSHIRENCHU5WANYUANYISHANG10WANYUANYIXIADEFAKUAN,BINGDIAOXIAOQIKANCHA、CAIKUANGXUKEZHENG”DEGUIDING,BINGJIEHEANSHECAIKUANGQUANYIJINGGUOXIANJIHESHIJIZIYUANZHUGUANBUMENPIZHUNDESHISHI,KEZHIZAILIAONINGSHENGCAIKUANGQUANJINGPIZHUNYIFAKEYICHUZU。

DANSHI,ZUIGAOFAYUANZAISHENLIGAIANSHI,BINGMEIYOUYINYONGGAIDIFANGXINGFAGUI,ERSHIYINYONGLE《TANKUANGQUANCAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGGUANLIBANFA》(1998NIANDE309HAOWEN)DISANSHILIUTIAODIERKUAN“KUANGYEQUANDECHUZU、DIYA,ANZHAOKUANGYEQUANZHUANRANGDETIAOJIANHECHENGXUJINXINGGUANLI,YOUYUANFAZHENGJIGUANSHENCHAPIZHUN”DEGUIDING。

DUIYUBENANERYAN,KEYILIJIEZUIGAORENMINFAYUANCANZHAOSHIYONG《KUANGYEQUANCHURANGZHUANRANGGUANLIZANXINGGUIDING》(GUOTUZIFA[2000]309HAO)DEKUZHONG。DIYI,GAIFALVGUIFANXINGWENJIANZHIDINGYU2000NIANYU《LIAONINGSHENGKUANGCHANZIYUANGUANLITIAOLI》(1997NIAN)XIANGBI,JULISHENPANSHIJIANGENGJIN;DIER,GAIGUIFANXINGWENJIANDEZHIDINGJIGUANSHIYUANGUOTUZIYUANBU,ZUOWEIKUANGCHANZIYUANJIKUANGYEQUANXINGYEZHUGUANJIGUAN,QIZHIDINGDEGUIFANXINGWENJIANGENGJIEJINLIFAQUSHI。

3.运用法律解释选取最终适用的法律规范

SUIRANSHENLIFAGUANZHUYIDAOLECAIKUANGQUANZULINYUCAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGJUYOUBENZHIQUBIE,DANSHIJIEZHU309HAOWENDISANSHILIUTIAODIERKUAN,FAGUANRENDINGCAIKUANGQUANZULINSHICAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGDEJUTIXINGSHIZHIYI。JIRANFALV、XINGZHENGFAGUIMEIYOUGUIDINGCAIKUANGQUANZULIN,ZESHIYONGCAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGDEYOUGUANFALVHEXINGZHENGFAGUI。YUSHI,SHENLIFAGUANWANCHENGLEYIGEFALVGAINIANHEFALVJIESHIDEFUZAZHUANHUAN,ZUIZHONGFALVYIJUZHIXIANGLE《HETONGFA》DISISHISITIAODIERKUAN“FALV、XINGZHENGFAGUIGUIDINGYINGDANGBANLIPIZHUN、DENGJIDENGSHOUXUSHENGXIAODE,YIZHAOQIGUIDING”JI《TANKUANGQUANCAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGGUANLIBANFA》DISHITIAODISANKUAN“PIZHUNZHUANRANGDE,ZHUANRANGHETONGZIPIZHUNZHIRIQISHENGXIAO”ZHIGUIDING。

福彩500走势图GENJUSHANGSHUYOUGUANGUIDING,ZUIGAORENMINFAYUANZUIZHONGRENDING,BENANANYOUWEICAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGHETONGJIUFEN,BINGRENDING:《LAOBIANQIANGJINKUANGZULINXIEYISHU》YIHEFACHENGLI,SHANGWEISHENGXIAO。

五、关于采矿权租赁合同效力认定的变迁

福彩500走势图 CAIKUANGZULINHETONGXIAOLIDERENDINGWENTI,SHIJISHANGYUCAIKUANGQUANZULINHETONGSHIFOUNENGBEIJIESHIWEICAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGHETONGJINMIXIANGGUAN。

ZUIGAORENMINFAYUAN(2011)MINTIZIDI81HAOMINSHIPANJUESHUGONGBUHOUBUJIU,GAIANJIUBEI2012NIANDI3QIZUIGAORENMINFAYUANGONGBAOSUOKANDENG,CAIPANZHAIYAOWEI“YI、ZULINCAIKUANGQUANSHUYUYIZHONGTESHUDEKUANGYEQUANZHUANRANGFANGSHI,CAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGHETONGSHUYUPIZHUNHOUCAISHENGXIAODEHETONG。GENJUGUOWUYUAN《TANKUANGQUANCAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGGUANLIBANFA》DISHITIAODISANKUANDEGUIDING,CHUZUCAIKUANGQUANXUJINGYOUQUANPIZHUNDEJIGUANSHENPI,PIZHUNZHUANRANGDE,ZHUANRANGHETONGZIPIZHUNZHIRIQISHENGXIAO。ER、SUSONGZHONG,CAIKUANGQUANZULINHETONGWEIJINGPIZHUN,RENMINFAYUANYINGRENDINGGAIHETONGWEISHENGXIAO。CAIKUANGQUANHETONGSUIWEISHENGXIAO,DANHETONGYUEDINGDEBAOPITIAOKUANYIRANYOUXIAO。RUGUOYIFANGDANGSHIRENJUCIQINGQIUDUIFANGJIXULVXINGBAOPIYIWU,RENMINFAYUANJINGSHENCHARENWEIKEGUANTIAOJIANYUNXUDE,DUIQIQINGQIUYINGYUZHICHI;JIXUBAOPIQUEFAKEGUANTIAOJIANDE,YIFABOHUIQIQINGQIU。”

福彩500走势图YUSHI,GAIANGUANYUCAIKUANGQUANZULINXIEYISHUYUCAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGHETONG,ZIZIYUANZHUGUANBUMENPIZHUNZHIRIQISHENGXIAODERENDINGSIHUCHENGWEISIFAJIEDEGONGSHI。

DANSHI,SUIZHERENMENRENSHIDESHENHUA,ZUIGAORENMINFAYUANGUANYUCAIKUANGQUANZULINYUCAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGDEGUANXI、CAIKUANGQUANZULINXIEYISHIFOUSHUYUCAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGHETONGDEYIZHONGXINGSHIYOULEXINDEPANDUAN。ZHUYAOBIAOXIANZAIYIXIALIANGGEFANGMIAN:

1.个案审理中关于矿业权租赁合同的认识有了新突破

福彩500走势图2016NIAN11YUE3RI,(2016)ZUIGAOFAMINZHONG520HAOZUIGAORENMINMINSHIPANJUESHUJIUSHILIZHENG。ZAIGAIPANJUESHUZHONG,ZUIGAORENMINFAYUANRENWEI:“SHUANGFANGDANGSHIRENZHIJIANJIYU《ZULIN、GUQUANZHUANRANGHETONG》DEYUEDING,XINGCHENGANSHEYANJIANPOJINKUANGCAIKUANGQUANZULINJIXINAOSENGONGSIGUQUANZHUANRANGLIANGZHONGFALVGUANXI。JIUANSHEYANJIANPOJINKUANGCAIKUANGQUANZULINBUFENDEXIAOLIERYAN,KUANGYEQUANJIAOYISHIJIANZHONG,CUNZAIKUANGYEQUANRENZAIBUZHUANYIKUANGYEQUANQUANSHUDEQINGKUANGXIAJIANGKUANGYEQUANDEBUFENQUANNENGZAIYIDINGQIXIANNEIRANGDUJITARENSHIYONG、SHOUYI,BINGYOUTARENZHIFUZUJINDEJIAOYIMOSHI。KUANGYEQUANCHUZUJUYOUBUTONGYUKUANGYEQUANZHUANRANGDEFALVSHUXING,BUYISHIYONG《TANKUANGQUANCAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGGUANLIBANFA》DISHITIAODISANKUANGUANYU“PIZHUNZHUANRANGDE,ZHUANRANGHETONGZIPIZHUNZHIRIQISHENGXIAO”DEGUIDING,YIWEIJINGPIZHUNWEIYOUJINGXINGRENDINGKUANGYEQUANCHUZUHETONGJUYOUXIAOLIXIACI。TONGSHI,YIYINGZUNZHONGKUANGYEQUANCHUZUZAIJIAOYISHICHANGZHONGDEXIANSHICUNZAIHESHIJIANYIYI,BUYIJIANGQILISUODANGRANDISHIWEIKUANGYEQUANDEBIANXIANGZHUANRANGHUOZHEFEIFADAOMAIMOULIXINGWEI,YIGAIYUYIJINZHI。”

2.《最高人民法院关于审理矿业权纠纷案件适用法律若干问题的解释》(法释〔2017〕12号,以下简称12号文)对采矿权租赁合同的认识有了新变化

12HAOWENDISHIERTIAOGUIDING:“DANGSHIRENQINGQIUQUERENKUANGYEQUANZULIN、CHENGBAOHETONGZIYIFACHENGLIZHIRIQISHENGXIAODE,RENMINFAYUANYINGYUZHICHI。KUANGYEQUANZULIN、CHENGBAOHETONGYUEDINGKUANGYEQUANRENJINSHOUQUZUJIN、CHENGBAOFEI,FANGQIKUANGSHANGUANLI,BULVXINGANQUANSHENGCHAN、SHENGTAIHUANJINGXIUFUDENGFADINGYIWU,BUCHENGDANXIANGYINGFALVZERENDE,RENMINFAYUANYINGYIFARENDINGHETONGWUXIAO。”

福彩500走势图YOUCIKEZHI,ZUIGAORENMINFAYUANGUANYUCAIKUANGQUANZULINHETONGFALVXIAOLIDEBUTONGRENSHI,GENYUANYUCAIKUANGQUANZULINHETONGFALVXINGZHIDEBUTONGRENSHI,JICAIKUANGQUANZULINHETONGSHICAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGHETONGDEYIZHONG,HAISHIDULIDEHETONGLEIXING。SHIJIANZHONG,CAIKUANGQUANZULINHETONGYUCAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGHETONGZAISHIFOUBIANGENGCAIKUANGQUANZHUTI、ZULINFANWEI、DUIJIAZHIFUFANGSHI、LVXINGQIXIANDENGFANGMIANDOUYOUMINGXIANQUBIE。

YINCI,SIFAJIESHI(12HAOWEN)JIANGCAIKUANGQUANZULINHETONGFENWEILIANGZHONGLEIXINGYUYIGUIFAN:DIYI,YOUYUXIANXINGFALVFAGUIBINGBUJINZHICAIKUANGQUANZULIN,GUIZHIDEZHISHIYIZULINSHOUDUANZHUANRANGKUANGCHANZIYUANDEXINGWEI,ERQIECAIKUANGQUANZULINZAIXIANSHISHENGHUOZHONGYOUYOUGUANGFANCUNZAIDEXIANSHIXUYAO,YINCIDUIYUYIBANDECAIKUANGQUANZULINHETONG,ZUNZHONGDANGSHIRENZHIJIANDEYISIZIZHI,ZIHETONGYIFACHENGLIZHIRIQISHENGXIAO。ZHEIZHONGRENSHICHEDIDIANFULEYUANLAIJIANGCAIKUANGQUANZULINJIESHIWEICAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGJINERSHIYONGCAIKUANGQUANZHUANRANGHETONGZIPIZHUNZHIRIQISHENGXIAODEFALVLUOJI。DIER,DUIYUMINGWEIZULIN,SHIWEIZHUANRANGDECAIKUANGQUANZULINHETONG,ZEYIJUHETONGFADIWUSHIERTIAOGUIDING“YIHEFAXINGSHIYANGAIFEIFAMUDE”RENDINGWEIWUXIAOHETONG。

网站编辑:宫莉

最新棋牌赢现金游戏---首页_欢迎您 大发快三彩票是否合法-Welcome 大乐透开奖走势图结果---首页_欢迎您 红包扫雷app软件大全-Welcome 彩票代理怎么拉人---HOME_欢迎您